top of page

Jacob Riis was a photographer and a writer who wrote How the Other Half Lives. He was born in Denmark but emigrated to United States in 1870.  He used his camera as a tool to capture people who live in harsh conditions, such as crowded tenements and dangerous slums, and published the images in the public to catch people's attention. Thomas Nast, known as the 'Father of the American Cartoon', produced sarcastic art during the 19the century to criticize political figures in the society. He was born in Germany but moved to New York when he was around 6. (Bio.com)

In 1870, Jacob Riis became a police reporter for New York Tribune. Working as a reporter, he is able to write stories about New York City slums and to learn about immigrants neighborhoods, which serve as a focus of his calls for social reform. He used his camera to take pictures of the poor. His book, How the Other Half Lives, was published in 1890 with the photographs he took, and it revealed the horrible living conditions in the slums where the lower class of New York City lived. It analyzed the details of how did the housing problems affect the poor immigrants(open collections program) , including diseases, sanitation, and ovecrowding situations. Much of the sympathy came from his own experience of joblessness, hunger and homelessness as an immigrant. (portfolio at NYU) He argued that the tenements in New York should be reformed, that poverty was a result of imperfect social and economic system. He claimed that the it could be eliminated by increasing government regulation of the economy. (open collections program) He shocked many middle-class Americans with his sensational descriptures and pictures of tenement life in his book. (Pg 461, the unfinished nation)

Jacob Riis and Thomas Nast

Results:

I think Thomas Nast is really successful because his cartoon had captured public attention. Tweed was voted out of the office in the 1871 election. After that, Tweed was sent to jail. (MCNY Blog New York Stories) On the other hand, I think Jacob Riis is not as successful as Thomas Nast was because the solution didn't really solve the problem, because they just simply raze the slum without building any new housings to replace them. (Pg 461, the unfinished nation) However, his work had brought attention of one particularly important New Yorker, Theodore Roosevelt, who served as president of the New York Board of police commissioners. They became best friends and went to the slums together for further investigation. (open collections program)

 

 

Citation:

 

Bio.com

http://www.biography.com/people/jacob-riis

http://www.biography.com/people/thomas-nast-9420600  

 

Open Collections Program: Immigration to the US, Jacob Riis (1849-1914)

http://ocp.hul.harvard.edu/immigration/riis.html

 

Portfolio at NYU

http://journalism.nyu.edu/publishing/archives/portfolio/books/book287.html

 

MCNY Blog New York Stories

http://blog.mcny.org/2013/09/24/thomas-nast-takes-down-tammany-a-cartoonists-crusade-against-a-political-boss/

 

 

The unfinished nation: a concise history of the American people

Alan Brinkley - McGraw-Hill - 2010

 

Thomas Nast began his career in illustrating newspapers and magzaines, but eventually he began to make political cartoons. He worked for Harper's Magazine. His best remembered cartoon was about Boss Tweed in Tammany Hall. Tammany Hall was a New York city political organization which controlled the party's nominations. William.M.Tweed, the leader, was able to appoint several city officials and control city government. Therefore, he had the access to an enormous public money, and he used these money to enrich himself and his friend. It is estimated that he defrauded the city out of anywhere from $30million to 200million(equivalent to $365million to $2.4 billion today). Thomas Nast featured Tweed and his friend in many of his cartoons, particularly in 1870 and 1871. In order to stop him, Tweed send a representative to offer him $100,000 to study in Europe. But failing to bribe Nast, Tweed threatened the Harper's to boycott their textbooks. However, the board of Harper's chose to support Thomas Nast. (MCNY Blog New York Stories)

bottom of page